Blog

The umbrella rules changed in April. Your choice of umbrella may no longer be yours.

By Buzz Accounting · 2026-08-19

If you contract through an umbrella company, something changed on 6 April 2026 that you may only have noticed as an email from your agency saying your umbrella was no longer on its list.

The change itself is a tax liability rule, and it does not fall on you. Its effects, though, land on contractors first: fewer umbrellas to choose from, more agencies running their own payroll, and a fresh round of "keep 88% of your income" approaches to the people who get moved. This is what actually changed, what it means for your rate, and the five things worth checking on your next payslip.

What changed

The Finance Act 2025-26 inserted a new Chapter 11 into the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003, with matching National Insurance rules. From 6 April 2026, where a worker is supplied through an umbrella company:

The umbrella company keeps the primary duty to operate PAYE and pay it over. That has not changed.
The party immediately above the umbrella in the contractual chain is now jointly and severally liable for that PAYE and Class 1 National Insurance. In most arrangements that is the UK recruitment agency.
Where there is no agency in the chain, the liability falls on the end client instead.

Joint and several liability means HMRC can pursue either party for the whole amount and does not have to try the umbrella first. If an umbrella collects PAYE from the assignment rate and disappears without paying it, HMRC now sends the bill to the agency that supplied you.

Why that reaches your inbox

Before April, an agency's exposure to a non-compliant umbrella was reputational. Now it is financial and it is unlimited. The predictable responses have all happened at once:

Preferred supplier lists have shrunk. Agencies that once accepted any umbrella a contractor named now audit a handful and refuse the rest.
Some agencies have dropped umbrellas altogether and moved contractors onto agency PAYE or an in-house payroll.
Contractors are being switched mid-assignment, sometimes with a fortnight's notice, which means new starter paperwork, a new pension scheme and a break in accrued holiday.
The avoidance schemes have re-marketed themselves. Anything promising 85% to 90% take-home is the same disguised remuneration it always was, and the new liability rules do not protect the worker from an HMRC assessment.

What has not changed: IR35

Being paid through an umbrella is not the same thing as being inside IR35, and the two are constantly conflated.

IR35, or the off-payroll rules, determine whether an engagement with a personal service company should be taxed as employment. An umbrella company sidesteps that question entirely by employing you, so PAYE applies because you are an employee of the umbrella, not because of a status determination. Plenty of contractors work through an umbrella on engagements that would have been outside IR35, simply because the client will not deal with limited companies. Our post on IR35 for contractors covers the status rules themselves, which the April change leaves untouched.

Where a £450 day rate actually goes

The single most useful thing to understand about umbrella working is that the assignment rate is not your salary. It is the total the agency pays the umbrella, and every cost of employing you comes out of it before you have a gross wage at all.

The figures below are illustrative, for a steady month in 2026/27 on a tax code of 1257L, ignoring student loan repayments.

Working through it. The agency pays the umbrella £9,000. The umbrella takes its margin of £110, leaving £8,890 to cover both the employment costs and your wage.

Employer's National Insurance at 15% on everything above the £5,000 a year secondary threshold: £1,085.87.
Apprenticeship Levy at 0.5%, paid by umbrellas with a pay bill over £3m and passed on: £38.28.
Employer pension at the 3% auto-enrolment minimum on qualifying earnings between £6,240 and £50,270 a year: £110.07.

That leaves gross pay of £7,655.78, which already includes £824.49 of holiday pay at 12.07% of basic. Your holiday is not an extra: it is carved out of the same money.

Then the deductions any employee would see:

Income tax £2,014.97 — £628.33 at basic rate and £1,386.64 at higher rate.
Employee National Insurance £320.66 — 8% up to the upper earnings limit and 2% above.
Employee pension £183.45 at the 5% auto-enrolment minimum.

Net pay: £5,136.70. That is 57% of the assignment rate, plus £293.52 a month going into a pension you own. Nothing in that list is an umbrella overcharging you. It is what employing someone costs, moved onto the rate.

What this means for the rate you quote

In the example above, £9,000 of assignment value produced £7,655.78 of gross pay. The assignment rate has to sit about 17.6% above the gross pay you would have negotiated as a salaried employee, purely to fund the employer's costs. Put the other way round, a £450 umbrella day rate is a £382.79 gross-pay day rate, before a penny of income tax comes off.

That is the number to carry into a rate negotiation. Treat an umbrella rate and a limited company rate as the same figure and you have handed over the difference without discussing it. Our freelancer and contractor tax guide works through how the two compare once corporation tax and dividends are in the picture.

Five things to check this week

Find your Key Information Document. An agency must give you one before you agree to an assignment. It sets out the assignment rate, the expected deductions and an illustration of your likely gross pay. If you were switched to a new umbrella and never got a fresh one, ask for it.
Read the payslip properly. Employer's National Insurance, the Apprenticeship Levy and the umbrella margin should appear as costs met from the assignment rate, above your gross pay. If they appear as deductions from your gross pay, they are being taken twice and you should query it immediately.
Check HMRC has your pay. Sign into the HMRC app or your Personal Tax Account and confirm your umbrella is filing your pay and tax. This is the check that catches a failing umbrella early, and it takes about ninety seconds.
Look at how holiday pay is handled. Rolled up into each payment, or accrued and paid when you take leave? If it is accrued, check the balance every month. Unclaimed accrued holiday pay sitting with an umbrella you are about to leave is money people routinely walk away from.
Refuse anything promising 85% or more. There is no compliant structure that pays a higher-rate taxpayer 85% of their assignment rate. These are disguised remuneration schemes, and while the new rules put the PAYE liability on the agency, HMRC can and does assess the worker for the underpaid tax.

And one thing that is easy to forget

Umbrella employment is taxed at source, but it does not automatically end your Self Assessment obligations. You still need to file if you have other self-employed income, rental or dividend income, income over £150,000, or you want to claim relief on personal pension contributions at the higher rate. Contractors moving between umbrella months and freelance months are exactly the people who most often owe something in January and least expect to. Our page for contractors covers how the two sides sit together on one return.

Where we help

We handle the Self Assessment return for contractors running a mix of umbrella employment and freelance income, check that umbrella deductions match what the Key Information Document promised, and reclaim higher-rate pension relief that PAYE alone never gives you. Fixed fees from £19 + VAT a month. Get started.

Quick answers

About this post

What changed for umbrella companies on 6 April 2026?

PAYE and National Insurance on umbrella pay became a joint and several liability across the supply chain. The umbrella still has the primary duty to operate PAYE, but the party immediately above it in the contractual chain — usually the UK recruitment agency, or the end client where there is no agency — is now equally liable for the same tax. HMRC can pursue either party for the full amount without exhausting the other first. The rules sit in a new Chapter 11 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003, introduced by the Finance Act 2025-26.

Am I liable if my umbrella company fails to pay the PAYE?

Not under the new rules, which put the joint liability on the agency or end client rather than on you. The exception is avoidance: where a scheme has paid you through loans, annuities or anything else designed to look like something other than pay, HMRC can and does assess the worker directly for the underpaid tax, and the April 2026 rules do not change that. This is why the promise of 85% or 90% take-home is worth treating as a warning rather than an offer. Check on the HMRC app that your pay and tax are actually being reported.

Why is employer's National Insurance taken out of my rate?

Because the assignment rate is what the agency pays the umbrella, not a salary. Out of it the umbrella must fund every cost of employing you — employer's National Insurance at 15% above the £5,000 secondary threshold, the Apprenticeship Levy at 0.5%, the employer pension contribution, holiday pay and its own margin — and what remains becomes your gross wage. On a £9,000 month that is roughly £1,344 of employment costs before you reach gross pay. It is not an umbrella taking a second cut, but it does mean an umbrella rate and a limited company rate are not comparable numbers.

Can I still choose my own umbrella company?

Increasingly not. Because agencies now carry the tax liability if an umbrella fails to pay, most have cut their preferred supplier lists to a small number they have audited themselves, and some have stopped using umbrellas altogether in favour of agency PAYE. If your umbrella has been dropped you can ask the agency what its audit found, but you are unlikely to get an exception. Where you do have a choice, compare the margin, how holiday pay is handled and whether the pension provider is one you would keep, rather than the advertised take-home figure.

Is being paid through an umbrella the same as being inside IR35?

No, though they are constantly confused. IR35 and the off-payroll rules decide whether work done through your own limited company should be taxed as employment. An umbrella removes that question entirely by employing you directly, so PAYE applies because you are an employee, not because of any status determination. Many contractors work through umbrellas on engagements that would have been outside IR35, simply because the client refuses to contract with personal service companies. The April 2026 changes affect who is liable for umbrella PAYE and leave the status rules themselves untouched.

Is an umbrella offering 85% take-home legal?

No compliant umbrella can pay a higher-rate taxpayer anything close to 85% of their assignment rate, because income tax, both classes of National Insurance and the pension minimum take considerably more than that. Arrangements advertising those figures are disguised remuneration: part of the payment is routed through loans, annuities, capital advances or offshore structures that HMRC does not accept as non-taxable. The consequences fall on the worker as well as the scheme, through assessments for the underpaid tax plus interest, often years later. HMRC publishes a list of named tax avoidance schemes and promoters worth checking against.

Do I still need to file a Self Assessment return if I am paid through an umbrella?

Often yes. Umbrella pay is taxed at source, but a return is still required if you have self-employed or freelance income alongside it, rental or dividend income above the allowances, income over £150,000, or child benefit to reconcile. It is also how you claim higher-rate relief on personal pension contributions, which PAYE does not give you automatically. Contractors who move between umbrella months and freelance months are the group most likely to owe something in January and least likely to have set money aside for it.

What is a Key Information Document and should I have one?

It is a document an employment agency must give you before you agree to an assignment, setting out who pays you, the assignment rate, the deductions that will be made and an illustration of the pay you can expect to receive. It exists precisely so that the gap between a headline day rate and net pay is visible before you commit. If you were moved to a new umbrella part way through an assignment and never received a fresh one, ask for it, and compare the illustration against your first payslip line by line.

Free · straight to your inbox

Liked this? Get the next one.

Practical freelancers and the self-employed tax and money tips by email — no jargon, unsubscribe any time.

No spam, no jargon. Unsubscribe any time.